I started this post in early January, but never published it. Cookies in January? hmmm.
Sparkly sugar optional.
I didn't publish that post because I figured you (and I) ate a few too many cookies in December. Maybe you also baked too many, and you were a little...over cookies. You were all about the New Year, and Taking Vigorous Walks, and Eating Mindfully.
Well, a little time has passed, just enough that it's safe again to talk about cookies.
In early December, I started to think about "the" cookie I'd be baking to give to some friends. You see, each December I join some dear mom buddies of mine in an 8-way cookie swap. We make our exchange at a big annual potluck party with the dads and the kids and homemade eggnog and lots of extra cookies for dessert.
In the past, I've leafed through favorite cookbooks and consulted my swap partners to choose the cookie recipe I'll use. One year I made lemon sugar cookies; another year it was chocolate gingerbread.
This year, it came to me suddenly one day as I stood in the kitchen: I wanted a fudgy peanut butter cookie. Not a chocolate chip peanut butter cookie (which is yummy in its own way) but rather a dark cocoa cookie with a hint of peanut butter.
Now, I wish I could say I experimented with my favorite peanut butter cookie recipe (Better Homes and Gardens--perfection IMO) but instead, I went straight to my favorite cookie cookbook, opened the chapter on Nut Cookies, and there they were: Peanut Butter Fudge Cookies.
These cookies call for three kinds of chocolate--unsweetened; American-style cocoa; and chopped milk chocolate chips. Despite all that chocolate, the peanut butter flavor still comes through. And, although kids love these cookies, they are not too sweet.
I caution you that it's tricky to bake these, because you can't tell if they're browning: they're already dark to begin with. If you bake them too long (like I did for the cookies I traded at the swap!!! argh), they become so tough you can barely bite into them. They should be melt-in-your-mouth consistency, like a soft butter cookie. So, do yourself a favor and bake a tiny sample batch before you really get cranking.
These make wonderful icebox cookies. I made an enormous batch in December and rolled them into short 7 inch logs. Every now and then I pulled one out, set it on the counter for about 15 minutes, then sliced the dough into 1/4 inch thick cookies and baked them. And by the middle of January, we'd eaten them all. Time to take a Vigorous Walk.
Fudgy Peanut Butter Cookies
(Adapted from The All American Cookie Cookbook)
2 oz unsweetened chocolate, coarsely chopped
2 1/2 cups all-purpose white flour
1/2 tsp baking soda
1/4 tsp salt
1 cup plus 2T peanut butter
1 1/2 cups light brown sugar (packed)
1/3 cup sugar
1/3 cup unsweetened American style cocoa*
1 cup unsalted butter (slightly soft)
2 large eggs
2 tsp vanilla extract
6 oz. milk chocolate chips, finely chopped
Pre-heat the oven to 350 deg F.
Gently melt unsweetened chocolate using a double-boiler or microwave.
In a bowl, stir flour, baking soda, and salt; set aside. In a larger bowl, beat melted chocolate, peanut butter, brown sugar, sugar, and cocoa with a mixer until blended. Add the butter and beat until smooth. Add the eggs and vanilla and beat until fluffy, about 2 minutes. Beat in flour mixture, then the chopped chocolate chips, until evenly blended. Place dough in the fridge until it firms up a bit.
At this point, I rolled the dough into "logs"--mine were about 6 or 7 inches long and and 1 1/2 in. thick--and wrapped the ones I didn't need to bake right away in wax paper. The logs could be stored in the fridge or freezer (depending on your plans) before baking.
As I mentioned, bake a small sample batch of 2 cookies before baking up all the dough. Try baking them for 8 minutes and then cooling them completely before sampling--this will give you an idea of how long to bake the rest. I found that baking them 10 minutes sometimes resulted in a super hard cookie once they'd cooled well, so you want to err on the side of less rather than more.
* for my international friends, I tried to figure out if you can use Dutch-style cocoa instead; you can try it, but be cautious; American cocoa has more acid, and in recipes (like this one) with baking soda, the author may be expecting the acid in the American cocoa to react with the baking soda as a leavening (making the cookies rise).










